Showing posts with label constitution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label constitution. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Get a Lawyer!

Get a Lawyer!

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on December 22, 2010.

I, dear reader, watch an almost embarrassingly large amount of television. It is one of my vices. There are worse things.

One of the types of shows I enjoy the most involve the police in some way. If you've watched almost any television in the past twenty years, you know the type. There are classics like the Law & Order franchise, Homicide: Life on the Street, and Hill Street Blues; there are variations on the theme like the CSI franchise; and newer shows like Medium, The Mentalist, and Blue Bloods.

If you've watched almost any television in the past twenty years, you've also heard the Miranda warning. The warning, which the Supreme Court has ruled must be given to suspects of crimes before they are questioned, goes like this:

"You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law. You have the right to speak to an attorney, and to have an attorney present during any questioning. If you cannot afford a lawyer, one will be provided for you at government expense."

The verbal warning is kept relatively short, so that police can recite it quickly (which is good, for TV), but there is a much longer version, almost three times longer, that is more comprehensive and is usually given in written form.

The key components of the Miranda warning, spoken or written, are these: the right to remain silent, the right to an attorney, and the fact that your own words can be used against you.

The point of all this is the dismay that I feel when watching some of these favorite police shows of mine. You might think, with my build-up above, that my problem is that police in these shows tend to forget the Miranda warning. Actually, to my memory, most television cops are very good about giving the Miranda warning, and many scenes end with a suspect being carted off in handcuffs for questioning as the arresting officer starts reciting, sometimes in a rote monotone, "You have the right to remain silent..."

No, it is not the TV cops' treatment of the Miranda warning that causes me dismay. It is that most suspects seem to forget all of their rights as soon as they step into a police station.

I certainly understand the need to move the story along, and watching a suspect sit and wait for a lawyer is hardly compelling TV. In fact, a lawyer-supervised interrogation is also hardly compelling - much more TV-friendly is the tearful or angry confession, caused by a detective asking just the right question or a suspect being caught in a lie. And I have to admit a certain degree of schadenfreude when a smug suspect, whom the audience is well-aware is guilty, slips up and realizes they've just confessed to the crime.

What I'm afraid of, what my dismay is all about, is that as people watch these shows, and see these suspects spill their guts with a lawyer no where in sight, they will begin to think nothing of it - that should they ever find themselves in that situation, the best or perhaps only option, the Miranda warning be damned, is to confess and take their punishment.

As a civil libertarian, I want everyone to know their rights and exercise them to their fullest extent. But don't get me wrong - in the end, with their rights intact, I want the guilty to be punished to the fullest extent. What I wish is that these shows could figure out a way for suspects to be represented by counsel and still get their just rewards.

Perhaps it is too much to ask - that a suspect exercising his right to counsel can still be compelling drama. But there has to be a way, and I issue a challenge to the writers of Hollywood to not only write such story lines, but to make them the majority rather than the minority. Unfortunately, I don't know any Hollywood writers.

What I have, dear reader, is you. God forbid you should ever find yourself as a suspect in a crime. But if you do, don't go down the route taken by too many TV characters. Exercise your rights and get yourself a lawyer; don't answer any questions without that lawyer present; and for goodness' sake, follow your lawyer's advice.

Thursday, October 28, 2010

On Amending the Constitution

On Amending the Constitution

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on October 28, 2010.

You'll notice an unusual item on your ballot on November 2 - a vote on an amendment to the Vermont Constitution. Its appearance gives me a chance to discuss the long road that an amendment to the Vermont Constitution has to travel, and how widely the procedure varies from amending the United States Constitution.

The process for amending any constitution should not be an easy one - a constitution is the basic law of a political unit, and provides a stable foundation that can be relied on for years, decades, even centuries.

The process of amending the U.S. Constitution has a few different paths, not all of which have been taken.

The most common path is for the Congress to vote, by two-thirds concurrence in both houses, to recommend an amendment. It has never been an easy thing to get a two-thirds vote in Congress, and this high bar reflects the framers' thoughts that changes should only come with broad consensus.

After those votes, however, there is a final stage that can be just as hard to overcome. The amendment is then sent to the states, where three-quarters of them must ratify the amendment.

The states can ratify in one of two ways - by majority votes of each state's legislature (which is most often another two-part hurdle) or, if directed by the amendment itself, by a special ratifying convention called in each state.

This second option may seem like a bit of an end-run around the legislatures, and to some degree it is. However, depending on state law, it is the executive or legislature that must convene the convention, and a determined governor or legislature could refuse to do so or at least drag its heels.

In the case of Vermont, heel-dragging is not an option. The responsibility to convene a convention is given to the governor, who has only 60 days following an amendment proposal to call the convention. The process then involves the voters, who choose 14 people from a list of 28 compiled by the governor, lieutenant governor, and speaker of the house.

The election must take place between three and 12 months after the governor's call, and the convention itself must take place 20 to 30 days after the election. The convention is free to conduct itself in any way it decides, and a majority vote on the proposed amendment, either way, decides the issue.

The convention route for a constitutional amendment has only been used once - to ratify the 21st Amendment, which repealed the 18th Amendment and made liquor again legal in the United States.

The second, unused method for proposing amendments is by a convention of all the states. Many fear what amendments could come out of such a convention, and that fear has, in my opinion, been the main reason that many resist any call for an amendment convention.

Amending the Vermont Constitution is a longer process, by design.

First, amendments may only be proposed every four years, beginning in 1975. The Senate must initiate the process, and must approve the amendment by two-thirds vote. The House must then approve the amendment by a majority vote. The last year an amendment could be proposed was 2007 and the next is 2011.

Once this first hurdle is crossed, the amendment must lay dormant until the next two-year legislative session. The amendment is then taken up again and must be approved by a majority of both houses of the legislature. If those votes are successful, the amendment has one final hurdle - the people.

That is the stage the voting age amendment has reached this year. If a majority of Vermonters approve the amendment, it will become a part of our Constitution; if not, it will have to wait until 2011 for another go.

Both methods have pros and cons. The method used by Vermont would probably be unworkable for an electorate on the scale of the United States, so even though there is value in getting the direct voice of the people, the methods already in place work well enough. The nation needs a way to rapidly change its constitution in a time of crisis, so the built-in speed bumps in the Vermont amendment process could actually be dangerous for the federal constitution.

When you go to the polls next week, be sure not to miss the question on the constitutional amendment presented to you. It is a rare opportunity for you to voice how our constitution should be constructed.

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Arizona law is unconstitutional

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on July 29, 2010.

Note: this entry was written before certain provisions of the Arizona law were stayed by a federal judge.

Arizona law is unconstitutional

Two weeks ago, I wrote about the history of immigration in America, focusing on discrimination that various ethnic groups have suffered. In particular, I focused on the most recent groups to suffer, Hispanics and Latinos.

What I did not get into was the most recent issue, the state-level immigration policies that are scheduled to go into effect today in Arizona. The state law requires immigrants in Arizona to carry their immigration papers with them at all times. If a state or local law enforcement officer has a suspicion that any particular individual is an illegal immigrant, they are required to question that person about their immigration status.

The law has been excoriated by many other state and local governments, many going so far as to put official boycotts of Arizona in place, forbidding, for example, attendance at conferences held in Arizona. This is not to say that there is no support for the law. Nine states, including those as diverse as Michigan and Alabama, have officially endorsed the law in legal briefs.

According to Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox, "Arizona, Michigan and every other state have the authority to enforce immigration laws." Here, Cox is simply incorrect. Cox went on to lament that the Obama Administration was spending tax payer dollars fighting the Arizona law.

There are two major problems with this law, and they both run smack into the supreme law, the U.S. Constitution. The first is found in two parts of the original text of the Constitution, at Article 1, Section 8, Clause 4; and at Article 6.

Article 1, Section 8 is all about the powers of the federal government. The powers listed therein are not shared by the federal government and state governments. They are exclusively federal. These include the power to coin money, to establish post offices, to establish patents and copyrights, and the power to maintain an army and navy. In that list is Clause 4, which grants the power to establish a "uniform rule of Naturalization." In this context, "naturalization" is an umbrella term that includes immigration policy.

States can argue that this clause does not, actually, include immigration, but they would then have to argue against almost 200 years of established legal precedent on the matter. The ability of states to convince the Supreme Court that its precedent on this issue is incorrect seems unlikely.

Article 6 simply buttresses this argument by noting that the Constitution, and laws made under it, are the supreme law of the United States. A law passed by a state that impinges upon federal powers is no law at all.

Finally, the law violates the 14th Amendment, which guarantees all persons due process under the law. Laws cannot be applied arbitrarily and capriciously. We rely on the judgement of our police officers for many things, and I applaud and support them in the application of that judgement. But here, Arizona police officers will have to make decisions about people based on their perception of an individual. What distinguishes a legal Latino immigrant from an illegal Latino immigrant? Is there something you can see in their eyes? A change in their skin tone? A certain scent a police officer can pick up? Anything, at all, that an officer can use as an objective measuring stick?

No, there is not. Either they will have to ignore the law or they will have to consider all persons who do not have their proper papers as illegals. The casting of this wide net will undoubtedly catch illegal immigrants. But it will just as undoubtedly catch legal immigrants and even native-born citizens of the United States.

Even if immigration was not the exclusive bailiwick of the federal government, these terms of the law are enough to render it null and void. It is my sincere hope that the courts that hear the case smack this law down with the full force of Constitution and send a message to all states that such a usurpation of federal authority will not be tolerated.

If the Obama Administration should be spending tax payer dollars anywhere, it is in fighting state violations of the Constitution. We have, after all, already fought a civil war over the issue of states trying to override federal authority over powers granted to it in the Constitution. What would be a waste, morally, legally, and constitutionally, is to not fight Arizona's law.

Thursday, March 25, 2010

More than just a head count

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on March 25, 2010. The original column stated there are an estimated 118 million households in the United States. The 2008 census data actually puts that number at 113 million. I regret the error.

More than just a head count

It's been a busy few weeks at my website, USConstitution.net. I was expecting it to be busy, but I expected the questions to be all about the health care bill and congressional rules and procedures. The bulk of the email I've gotten though, was about something completely different.

The subject of interest is perhaps best illustrated by this question: "Is there a place in the Constitution that says that I don't have to answer all the questions asked by the census?"

The question seems to come from a place of paranoia that I just cannot quite get my head around. Before I address that, though, a little history about the census itself might be interesting.

When the framers of the Constitution came to their great compromise between the small and large states, they created a bicameral Congress: one house with equal representation, the Senate, and one with proportional representation, the House of Representatives. This was a great departure from the Congress created by the Articles of Confederation, where each state had an equal voice.

To ensure that the proportional representation, or apportionment, in the House was fair, the Constitution requires the Congress to conduct a census every ten years. Until that first census, the Constitution guessed at proportions, with small Delaware and Rhode Island garnering one representative each and the largest state, Virginia, getting ten.

The very first census was held in 1790. The Constitution allows the Congress to conduct the census in "such manner as they shall by law direct." From the very beginning, the law directed that the census be more than a simple head count.

In that first census, which was conducted by census marshals and deputies who visited each home, the questions asked included the name of the head of household and the gender, race, slave status, and age of each person. The slave status was necessary because slaves were counted as three-fifths of a whole person, a slight remedied by the 14th Amendment.

Fast-forward to 2010, and the release of the 2010 census form. The questions on the form are not so different today as they were back in 1790. It asks for the name, gender, birth date, age, race, ethnicity, and relationship to the head of household of each individual. For the entire household, there are questions about whether the dwelling is rented or owned and for the household phone number.

These questions are not overly intrusive. The courts have said as much - the Supreme Court blessed non-headcount questions in 1870, and lower courts affirmed them as late as 2000. The questions form the basis for a relatively comprehensive look at the American population, and because similar questions have been asked since 1790, we have a wealth of information about our changing demographics over time.

Yet there are still those who question the questions, and feel certain that the Constitution must allow people to refuse to answer them.

The Constitution, of course, does not have a provision to allow you to refuse to answer. In fact, the Constitution explicitly gives the Congress the power to ask them - the census is to be conducted in such manner as the Congress requires by law. This statement seems pretty straightforward.

If nothing else, the census has become less intrusive in recent years. The form in 2010 has about ten questions; the 2000 census form was basically the same. In 1990, however, the 200th anniversary of the census, the census had 33 numbered questions for individuals and 26 for the dwelling. Filling out the form could take hours.

Some three million households, of an estimated 113 million, will get a longer form this year - a copy of the American Community Survey. This survey goes into the sort of detail the 1990 survey asked of all households. The information is required by law, so if you get one, you should take the time to fill it out. The questions asked can seem intrusive - what sort of fuel do you use for cooking, for example - but the answers can help the Congress, and even our own state legislature, make critical policy choices.

The answer to the question posed to me is no, there is no provision in the Constitution giving you the right to refuse to answer census questions. The head count is crucial to proper apportionment of the House, but beyond that, accurate answers can help shape policy for years to come.

Wednesday, November 25, 2009

It's Time to Kill the Filibuster

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on November 25, 2009.

It's Time to Kill the Filibuster

A few weeks ago in these pages, I took issue with those who insist we live in a democracy, explaining that a democracy is not an ideal system for a population of any significant size. Our system of representative democracy, where we hire, or elect, people to represent us, is a much better way of running a government.

Along with this indirect form of representation, we have protections in our system to ensure that the majority does not act as a tyrant. Our constitutions, for example, protect the freedoms of all, especially those of the minority.

Given all this, I feel the time is right to rail against one of my least favorite "features" of our legislative process — the filibuster.

The word derives from a Dutch term for a type of pirate. The term was first applied to American adventurers who sought to overthrow Central American governments in the 19th century, and was transferred to Senators who attempt to do the same to legislation.

The filibuster has a long history. At their inception, both houses of Congress allowed for unlimited debate — which is a fancy way of saying that a member of Congress could talk for as long as they wished, on any subject. While the member spoke, no other business could be conducted. If you could get two-like minded members to team up, that house of Congress would grind to a halt.

This is the exact opposite of a democratic principle, a tyranny of one.

The House long ago did away with this practice, as the number of Representatives rose. The Senate, however, retains the practice. For over 100 years, there was no way to stop debate. In 1917, the Senate created the cloture rule. Under the cloture rule, if enough Senators vote to stop debate, it stops. Originally, the number needed to invoke cloture was two-thirds, or 67 Senators in today's Senate. In 1975, the number needed to invoke cloture was reduced to three-fifths, or 60 Senators.

There have been several famous filibusters through history. Some are the stuff of legend — Huey Long, Democrat of Louisiana, filibustered the Senate multiple times in the 1930s, as he railed against legislation he felt gave too much to America's upper class. He entertained the nation by reading the phone book, Shakespeare, and the Bible into the public record.

Some filibusters had nothing short of evil intent. Strom Thurmond, Democrat (and Republican) of South Carolina, filibustered for over 24 hours to stop civil rights legislation in 1957. Other anti-civil rights filibusters were the norm until 1964, when the Senate was finally able to move the issue forward.

We have made some progress from the tyranny of one, to the tyranny of the third, to the tyranny of the two-fifths. I am a proponent for the protection of the minority, but the main protection for the minority is the Constitution, not an arcane Senate rule. It is time, has been time for a long time, to remove this technical procedure altogether.

Lest you think that this is just some sour grapes, the result of the recent close vote on cloture to allow the Senate's version of the health care bill to come to the floor, I admit that's part of it. It isn't like I sit around mulling over the filibuster and cloture every day.

But the recent vote only brought the issue to the foreground. I've disliked the filibuster and cloture for as long as I can remember. I would support doing away with it when the Senate is controlled by Republicans, too.

Not only is the filibuster anti-democratic, it is also ripe for abuse. Recent reports that Louisiana Senator Mary Landrieu's vote for cloture was bought with a $100 million gift to Louisiana is just another side of the problem — to get to cloture, the majority party might be willing to buy votes.

Whether that happened here or not is not relevant — what is relevant is that it can happen, that it has happened before, that it will happen again.

I'm thankful that the Senate voted to allow the health care bill to come to the floor for debate. It is a good step in the right direction. Once we have this important piece of legislation properly vetted, debated, amended, and passed, hopefully the Senate will take a close look at its rules, and decide that the time of the filibuster has long since gone.

Note: The orginally published text said "tyrrany of the quarter" — this text corrects that to "tyranny of the third."

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Constitutional FAQ

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on October 1, 2009.

Constitutional FAQ

One of the most popular pages on my U.S. Constitution web site is the FAQ. As you may already know, "FAQ" stands for "Frequently Asked Questions." The concept is to place such questions in a central location so that as the same questions arise again and again, the answers can be quickly found.

Despite the FAQ, I still get a lot of the same frequently asked questions, especially, it seems, from students who have come to expect that answers should fall into their laps, rather than come to them through a bit of research. I find these to be "teachable moments," and often refer these students to specific sections of the Constitution, writing "If you read this section, you'll find your answer."

The past year has brought about a whole new set of questions that I had not seen before — whether they will attain "Frequently Asked" status or not, only time will tell.

One perfectly reasonable question often goes like this: "I've searched through the Constitution and cannot find the words 'health care' anywhere. What gives Congress the right to enact health care legislation at all?"

Parenthetically, I usually tell such questioners that the Congress doesn't have "rights" to do anything. It does, however, have the "power" to do things. The discussion of rights versus powers is sometimes an overwhelmingly philosophical one, but the distinction is important.

That detail aside, the answer to many questions of this type have the same answer: Article 1, Section 8 is a list of the powers of Congress. Some of them are quite specific and limited (for example, the power to coin money or establish post offices).

Others, however, are succinct in their phrasing but expansive in their practical effects. Clause 1 is one of the most expansive, granting Congress the power to collect taxes in order to, among other things, provide for the "general Welfare" of the United States.

If health care cannot be called a component of the general welfare of the people, nothing can be.

Clause 18 completes the picture. This clause grants Congress the power to make all laws "necessary and proper" to carrying out the powers listed previously. Whether the Framers of the Constitution understood what they had done when they wrote clauses 1 and 18 is a subject of some debate in historical and political science circles, but for all practical purposes the debate is settled.

When the Bush and Obama administrations were bailing out troubled banks, a common question went like this: "Under what authority does the government gain control of private business by giving or loaning them taxpayer money?"

The answer is another expansive clause of Article 1, Section 8; Clause 3, the interstate commerce clause. Under this clause, paired with Clause 18 again, the Congress has the power to enter into arrangements with business such as it did at the beginning of this year. I hasten to note that the government was not looking for an actual take-over of the affected businesses, but some degree of control was thought necessary (and proper, if you'll forgive the constitutional pun) to bring banks under control. This would give Congress and government agencies time to come up with new regulations to prevent such crises in the future, once the direct government influence of the businesses was removed.

Finally, this question came to me recently: "How does the Constitution say the people can kick out the Congress or the President?"

Questions such as these bemuse me, and it happens quite often. A plain reading of the Constitution reveals that there is nothing like a "recall clause", but the questioner assumes it must be there.

In my response, I told the questioner that there is no such clause in the Constitution, and that it was actually a good thing that it's not there. Recall efforts are disruptive and take attention away from the work that the Congress or the President should be doing. If a member of Congress or the President acts in an egregious manner, there are ways of removing them from office (to wit, impeachment). Short of that extreme and rare measure, the people are free to exercise their rights of free speech, of petition, and, ultimately, the power of the vote.

Thursday, April 16, 2009

Tempering Faction

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on April 16, 2009.

Tempering Faction

I was recently asked a question about the Constitution that comes through my email box every so often in one of two forms. The first is "Where are political parties mentioned in the Constitution?" The second is "How does the Constitution support the two-party system?"

The first question is the easier one to answer. The Constitution does not mention political parties at all. Political parties evolved in our system after the ratification of the Constitution, so it would have been great foresight for the Constitution to have included them.

However, even in the later amendments, right up to those proposed and ratified in the 20th century, we managed to keep any mention of parties out of the Constitution.

The harder question is the second one, and it is a good question. Since the Civil War, the Republicans and Democrats have traded the presidency and control of the Congress. Rarely has a third party had a lasting effect.

Third parties have had a role to play in our political history, even if it was a fleeting role. Free Soil, Anti-Mason, Prohibition, Socialist, Reform, Green - these parties raised issues that the major parties eventually had to deal with.

The second question usually has a masked underlying question: Is the two-party system something positive, something worth retaining?

While there is something to be said for third parties, I think that we have a good thing with our two-party system, something worth retaining.

However, we also have something that some of our most influential founding fathers found to be a real issue in politics. The faction, better known today as "special interests."

Alexander Hamilton and James Madison, writing in the Federalist Papers as Publius, warned against special interests tearing at the fabric of society. Madison saw two ways of controlling factions: "The one, by removing its causes; the other by controlling its effects."

Madison knew it was pointless to remove the cause of faction, dangerous even. Only by removing liberty or by making all persons the same could the cause of faction disappear.

Better, then, to control the effect of faction. The federal system, with representative democracy, was his solution for the nation, the solution offered by the Constitution. In such a system, majority opinion is important, but minority rights are just as important, and protected.

Of course, factions still emerge. We see the divisions starkly, at the national, state, and local levels.

Pro-life versus pro-choice; for and against gay marriage; Option B versus Option C for our schools.

When factions are truly destructive is when the two sides cannot find common ground. On the most polarizing issues, common ground can be hard to find, especially when there are some on the fringes who will not budge. But there is almost always common ground to be found.

This is where discussion, compromise, and agreement come into play. The fringes can sabotage agreement, but only if they're allowed to. The larger part of any faction will be willing to compromise. Take the gay marriage debate as just one example.

When the state Supreme Court forced the issue in 1999, the state legislature heard from both sides - those who were adamantly opposed to gay marriage and those just as adamantly for it. By April of 2000, a compromise was reached, and civil unions became the law of this state.

Today, after nine years under that law, Vermonters decided that the advent of civil unions did not cause the downfall of society, and, in fact, enhanced it by granting similar rights to committed same-sex couples. In September, we will take the final step, and make marriage an institution available to any committed couple.

Through compromise and patience, the factions came together enough so that equal rights could be guaranteed.

It is a model for all factional disagreements that we face. The solution might not be perfect, but if found by compromise, it can at least be a shared victory, and when the opportunity arises again to reexamine the issue, lessons learned from the past can be applied.

This nation, this state, this community, all have had to deal with the passions of faction in the past. We deal with them now. We will deal with them in the future. The one thing I'm certain of is that through compromise, and patience, a suitable solution can always be found.

Thursday, January 8, 2009

A Conspiracy of the Truth

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on January 8, 2009.

A Conspiracy of the Truth

Some people still believe that any day now, a terrorist attack orchestrated by the Bush administration will be Bush's entré into a third term of office. Others, even a decade later, still believe that Bill Clinton ordered the death of Deputy White House Council Vince Foster.

There is little that one can do to counter such conspiracy theories, because even if you provide evidence to the contrary, the theorists suspect the evidence.

The Internet is already rife with Barack Obama conspiracy theories. I have had some personal interest in one in particular, not the least of which because I've been accused of helping cover up the conspiracy.

These theorists believe there is something amiss with Obama's status as a natural-born citizen. Being a natural-born citizen, according to Article 2, Section 1, of the Constitution, is a requirement for being president.

The requirement is an original part of the Constitution, not added to nor altered since 1787. The concept is so basic that it appears to have been added to the Constitution in committee, and never questioned nor modified by the Philadelphia convention. So basic, in fact, that the authors of the Federalist Papers felt no need to expand on the topic, as they did, copiously, on so many others.

The Obama natural-born theory actually has two main prongs.

The first says that Obama was not born in the U.S. at all, but instead in Kenya or Indonesia. His Hawaiian birth certificate is a fraud perpetrated on us by his parents, who, like seers, predicted his rise to power. Or a fraud perpetrated by Hawaiian officials desperate to see a native son assume the office.

The Obama campaign sought to put this theory to rest back in August, when it released copies of Obama's state-certified birth certificate to the press and to specific organizations, like FactCheck.org. The state-certified copy, of course, is suspect because state officials are suspect.

Though it is impossible to prove a negative, the theory does not pass the smell test. While any parent might have aspirations that their child might grow up to be president some day, to begin a conspiracy from the day of birth is too far-fetched to bear scrutiny; and I have no reason to doubt the honesty and veracity of Hawaiian state officials.

The second prong of attack goes along these lines: even given that Obama was born in Hawaii, his father was a British subject. As such, international law says that Obama's citizenship follows that of his father, and so Obama was born British, not American.

The sum of the true parts, however, do not add up to a true whole.

First, Obama's father was a British subject - Kenya, in 1961, was a British territory. Second, Emerich de Vattel's "Law of Nations," first published in 1758, does state, at section 212, "The country of the father is ... that of the children." Third, Vattel was well-known and distributed by the time of the drafting of the Constitution, and the Framers knew about it.

All truths, but all irrelevant. The Constitution, for one thing, was a repudiation of many of the "laws" put down by Vattel. His work spends a great deal of ink explaining a prince's responsibilities to his subjects, and those of the subjects to their prince. If these parts of Vattel are ignored by our Constitution, why not section 212 as well?

Further, and more importantly, Vattel was never the law of this land, and certainly not in 1961. In 1961, U.S. law stated what it states now - that a citizen at birth is "a person born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof."

Finally, the theorists take issue with me and my website, which treat the constitutional phrase "natural born citizen" and the law's phrase "citizen at birth" as synonymous. In doing so, I've been told, I am deliberately lying to the web-using public.

I defend these charges as best I can - in one out of ten cases, my correspondent is willing to listen. Most of the time, however, it is quickly apparent that the conspiracy theory has taken over all sense of reason, and I abruptly end conversation.

Barack Obama is a natural-born citizen of the United States of America. With our vote in November, the Electoral College's vote in December, and the counting of the votes in Congress scheduled for today, Obama's status as our president-elect is in no reasonable doubt.

Call it a conspiracy of the truth.

Friday, September 26, 2008

Back to (Electoral) College

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on September 25, 2008.

Back to (Electoral) College

Every four years, we Americans go back to college - the Electoral College. The Electoral College is important because despite conventional wisdom, it is not presidential candidates that we will vote for in November but instead the members of this exclusive college.

Officially, the President is chosen not by the people but by the states, and each state has as many votes as it has members of Congress. All states get at least three electoral votes - one for each Senator and Representative. Vermont, then, only gets three. California, by contrast, has 55.

These elector counts are how commentators can tell you how many electoral votes a candidate needs to win the election. There are 100 Senators and 435 Representatives in Congress, for a total of 535 electoral votes. Add three more for Washington, D.C., for a total of 538. You need half plus one to win outright, or 270.

It is these electors you are selecting when you cast your ballot in November, not the exact candidate, though each political party chooses its electors. In most states, including Vermont, the slate of electors that garners the most votes will vote in the Electoral College. The electors from the other parties get to watch from home like the rest of us.

After the electors all vote, the votes are bundled up and mailed off to Congress, where they are eventually opened and tallied, and a winner is officially declared.

This year, Election Day falls on November 4. Elector Day, when the electors gather in their state capitals to cast their votes, is December 15. Finally, the Congress will count the votes on January 6.

Most of this process is pro forma after Election Day. Though electors are not technically bound to vote for the candidate they are pledged to, they almost always do; and unless an elector goes against the grain, the reading of the votes in Congress is no surprise.

Why so convoluted a system? Why do we not just vote for the presidential candidate directly? The answer goes back to the great compromises the Framers made when they wrote the Constitution back in 1787.

The Electoral College does a few things. The biggest effect it has is to protect the smaller states, like Vermont, from the whims of the larger states. For one thing, large-state favorite sons can only get as many electoral votes as their state has; for another, because of equal suffrage in the Senate, smaller states have disproportionately large voting power in the College.

Another effect is our quadrennial reminder of the power of representative democracy. Just as we elect Senators and Representatives to weigh our demands with those of the nation, we elect electors to weigh our vote with the choices available. Even if the Electoral College always ends up voting as expected, there is always that slim possibility they could change their collective mind.

I have vacillated on the issue of the Electoral College over time, from supporter, to detractor, to compromiser.

As a resident of a small state, I am happy that my vote counts for more than a New York vote or a California vote. I am, however, uncomfortably happy, this being the equivalent of electoral schadenfreude.

The populist idea is a straight national popular vote. After the election debacle of 2000, I cringe, though, at any national plan. If there is dispute about the national vote, do we mandate Florida-style recounts in all 50 states? Would this grind the process to a halt?

Undoubtedly we could work something out, where recounts are by precinct or district or state, but still the prospect of needing a national recount is plausible. At least with the Electoral College as it is now, a recount in New York or New Hampshire does not necessitate a recount here.

A promising compromise is an interstate compact whereby, once enough states to total 270 or more electoral vote have signed on, those states would change their laws to select the slate of electors for the winner of the national vote, regardless of the state vote.

In any case, it is too late for change now, so the Electoral College process is going to go forward at least one more time. So, revel in our little electoral idiosyncrasy, and as homework, try to find out the names of the electors you'll be voting for when you cast your vote on Election Day.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Religious Testing

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on January 17, 2008.

Religious Testing

As you may remember from high school, the original Constitution contained no bill of rights, a fact lamented by some of the framers in Philadelphia. One of the main reasons George Mason refused to sign the Constitution, after a hot summer of work on the document, was the lack of a bill of rights.

Eventually, James Madison went to the House promising to champion a bill of rights, and three years after the Constitution was ratified, the first ten amendments were added.

What many forget is that the original Constitution contains what some have called a "mini" bill of rights. The protection of habeas corpus and the prohibition of ex post facto laws and bills of attainder are included in this small list.

In my discussions of constitutionally-protected rights, I include the final clause of Article 6:

"[N]o religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States."

The framers were creating a state based on democratic principles, not autocratic, not monarchic, not theocratic. This right, the right to not be required to adhere to one religion or another in order to hold office, was especially important in the Protestant melting pot of the 1780s.

The Religious Test clause was created in a society troubled by competing Christian sects. In a time when Baptists and Congregationalists were sometimes at each other's throats, the Religious Test clause was a big step.

Tolerating other Protestant sects was only one challenge. For many in 18th century America, reinstallation of a king would have been preferable to a large migration of Catholics into America. If there was any thought of "Hindoos," "Mohammedans," or any other major world religion, it was fleeting at best. Fortunately, we have evolved in our thinking and our Constitution has been able to adapt from tacit tolerance to actual tolerance.

What brings all this up is the resurgence of religiosity in our presidential campaigns these last few cycles. To be sure, our presidents are usually not shy about their beliefs. Dwight Eisenhower was baptized while in office; James Garfield sometimes took to the pulpit to preach while in office; and, of course, George W. Bush's religious rebirth was the subject of much ink before he became president.

However, outward displays of faith which were often considered undignified just a few decades ago are de rigueur today. In fact, "having religion" seems to be a requirement: polls show that most people would not vote for an avowed atheist or even an agnostic.

What concerns me is that all this talk of religion seems to have rendered the Religious Test clause moot. Though the people are free to vote for whomever they wish for whatever reasons they wish, if large enough blocs of voters impose such a test on the candidates they, in effect, impose it for all of us.

From concerns about Mitt Romney's Mormonism to evangelicals voting for Mike Huckabee solely because he is an ordained minister, talk of religion, in some circles in particular, has overtaken the really important issues. I find it more important to know candidate's thoughts on domestic and foreign policy than about the role God plays in their life.

Religion is also being used as a scare tactic. FactCheck.org recently debunked a series of emails that are circulating about Barack Obama, emails that erroneously report that Obama attended a jihadist madrassa in Indonesia, that he took his oath of office on the Koran, and that he attends a racist church in Chicago.

Even worse, these scare tactics work because so many people know absolutely nothing about religion. In his book "Religious Literacy," Stephen Prothero shows that the lack of knowledge about religion is not only sad but dangerous. In a time when many Catholics can't list the seven sacraments and many Protestants don't know who Martin Luther is, it is easy to scare people about Mormons or Muslims.

I don't think it is inappropriate to ask our candidates for president to reveal their religious beliefs. But I do hope that after we hear the answers, we don't close our minds to those who give an answer we perceive as "wrong."

Religion has a prominent place in American life, but when it comes to politics, our religious beliefs should guide us but not rule us. Don't judge someone simply because they are Baptist or Muslim or Mormon or Jewish or Catholic or even atheist.

Instead, listen to what they have to say about the issues and base your decisions on that. It is in keeping with the spirit of the Constitution's Religious Test clause, and in keeping with our American tradition of religious freedom and tolerance.

Thursday, January 3, 2008

A political wish list for 2008

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on January 4, 2008.

A political wish list for 2008

After receiving a Christmas wish list from one of my sons, I was asked, "What's on your wish list, daddy?" While I can do without a WebKinz or an iPod, there are some things I wish for the coming year.

Politically, and this should be no surprise, I wish more than anything for a Democrat to take the presidential elections in November. I'm still not sure, however, who I'd like that Democrat to be, but I have my favorites.

I also wish, as the deluge of political ads continue, that we in Vermont are spared much of the negative mudslinging that pervades the airwaves in other states. Let the newspapers report on candidates' problems. I want to know why to vote for you, and not why I should vote against your opponent.

I wish that we, the people, would see the insanity of our primary system. It will be no surprise to me to see the next Iowa caucus held in December 2011 if we don't fix things soon, and it will take the people's outcry to fix it.

My favorite plan is to split the country into equal quarters, and hold primary elections in each quarter all at once, perhaps two weeks apart, rotating which quarter goes first each election cycle. As much as I love New Hampshire and think Iowa is a fine state, there is little reason either should always get first crack at the candidates.

I wish that we could see an end to the undeclared war in Iraq. The details can fill an entire column, but suffice it to say I don't see a complete pull-out as a viable option. The Iraqis, however, need to be in charge of their own destiny. We should help with that, but we need an exit strategy, yesterday.

For my state, I wish for a continuation to our snow season, to keep our winter industries going. But not so much snow that the kids have any more snow days!

I wish that Vermont would do away with civil marriage. I think marriage is something that only churches should bestow. The state still has an interest in joining couples, and to that end, I think that civil union should replace marriage. As shocking as this idea might first seem, it would solve a lot of problems and avoid a lot of needless debate.

I wish that we, as a state, would make a commitment to alternative power generation. There are a lot of great ideas out there for wind power, solar power, and cleaner nuclear power, and we should be on the vanguard.

This is a bit of an obscure wish, but I wish Vermont would follow its own constitution and house all of our prisoners in-state. It might be more expensive, but if we can violate Article 2, Section 64 of our own constitution, is any part safe?

This may come as a surprise - I don't know if I wish for a Democrat in the governor's chair. I think there is real benefit to having the legislative and executive branches at odds with each other. Negotiation leads to better laws than collusion.

Within Williston, I wish for a resolution, one way or the other, to issues like the Circ, the use of guns on public lands, and the disposition of the proposed landfill. I also wish that the people would come out and hear about the school budget and offer up objections and suggestions long before the budget comes to a vote.

Speaking of voting, I wish Williston could claim 100% participation of eligible voters or, at least, registered ones. There are still people in this world who die to cast their vote - we should take the obligations of citizenship more seriously.

Lastly, I wish that we would all take a few minutes and read our constitutions, both national and state. It doesn't take long and it's worth the time. Find out or rediscover your rights, then exercise those rights: petition your government and speak out on the issues. Let them know what's on your wish list.

Thursday, December 13, 2007

The Good Fight

This column originally appeared in the Williston Observer on December 13, 2007.

The Good Fight

Liberals these days have a lot of mixed feelings.

We support the troops fighting in Iraq, but we don't support the fight in Iraq. Within the liberal ranks, we vary from demanding immediate withdrawal from Iraq to realizing that moving too quickly could be just as bad as doing nothing.

We want to unify strongly behind a presidential candidate, but there are too many good ones to choose from.

We don't like the Swift Boating that John Kerry was subjected to in the last election, but from Mitt Romney's flip-flops to Rudy Giuliani's trysts on the public's dime, we feel the temptation to do a little Swift Boating of our own.

We think that President Bush has committed acts that violate the Constitution and amount to more "high crimes and misdemeanors" than Bill Clinton's lies about sex in the Oval Office, yet we know the impeachment is a big step to take and conviction a high hurdle to jump over.

That's all national - it is another question altogether about how we feel about state politics. Incumbent governors have a hard time losing elections in Vermont, so do Democrats waste money and talent challenging Jim Douglas?

We want Vermont to be more green so lots of wind farms sound like a great idea, but we also love Vermont's pristine views and would hate to despoil the windiest parts of the state with giant monuments to technology.

More basic, do we support the Progressive Party because they share some of our values or do we support the Democrats because we want to win?

And locally, there are still more questions. What's more important to a liberal in Williston - your property tax bill or the programs that our schools provide to prepare our kids for the future?

Do we support safety and landowners' rights or the oft-overlooked and important rights of gun owners when it comes to the question of hunting in the town limits?

Is there even a "liberal" position on such local issues?

Of course, I can only write about my own thoughts and feelings on any issue. People speak of a liberal position on this or a conservative position on that, but these are general labels, and just as some conservatives support gun control or abortion rights, there are some liberals who support the war unconditionally or don't believe in global warming.

My own personal beliefs are tend to be on the left of center. This might have been surprising to some people who knew me in high school, when I supported Reagan for President and touted the logic of Mutually Assured Destruction.

Hopefully, when you read the words I put on these pages, you will nod your head with me one week and shake it in disagreement the next. This is one of the most wonderful things about America and American politics. Though we apply labels to ourselves and each other, we rarely live up to the label in ways that they do in other countries.

I will say up front that there is one thing that I do use to guide me, and that is my faith and belief in our constitutions. The constitutions of Vermont and the United States are wonderful and extraordinary documents. Constitutions can be unwieldy and untidy. Ever tried to read the Constitution of China or that of California?

The best constitutions give guidance only, but they also allow you to see, at a relatively quick glance, that which we hold most dear. I hope to explore some of that guidance, and how we handle it when reality conflicts with those ideals.

I hope you will take the journey with me.